Monday, June 22, 2009

Cloud Technology/Web OS/Online Desktop

Whatever you call it, you’re basically talking about a remote desktop that’s living on the web either house in the developer’s server or on your own website server.

 

Either way it’s a great idea for all of us on the move in this fast paced world; it just needs some more refinement.

 

I decided to check out all the mainstream developers and their products but I approached it from a unique angle: I’m a fiction writer with specific demands.

 

1. Has to have a Word/Document application that’s similar to MS Word in the way you can format your document with indentation, quotations for dialog, and etc..

2. When a document is saved it’s a “.doc” file that I can link to using a browser.

3. Preferably this is a service I can download and install on my own website server.

 

So, let’s see how they stack up.

 

EyeOS is the first one I tried out.  It stood out because (so far) it’s the only one that offers a version that I can download and install on my own web server.  I think that’s very impressive.

The desktop isn’t as 100% similar to a Windows desktop but its close enough to be understood as a desktop.

However, once it came to the document application everything went wrong.  First, the document editor is extremely cumbersome with, as far as I can tell, no way to indent the beginning of a paragraph.  Secondly, you could tweak a setting to get it to save a document as a .doc file but it’s so far buried in the folder system that you can’t link to it.

 

So, I have yet to uninstall this, but it falls short of my needs.  EyeOS is an open source project so people are welcome to make applications to run on it.  I pray that someone develops a better document application.  Currently there is a handful of other applications but be wary; many don’t work right.

 

 

Icloud is the second one on my list and this is purely a service provided by the developer.  Regardless, I thought I might be able to deal with the ‘account’ so long as it provided me with the other two specifics I needed.

The desktop itself is very much like windows.  In fact it attempts to be identical.  However, I run into all the same problems with the document application.  Even though this service has a great file tree and there’s a way to treat it as if it were a USB flash drive, it has the same poor application and no way to link to the files.

 

Cloudo is third and it’s a mirror of Icloud.  There are minor differences in the desktop and applications.  Icloud is 100% like Windows and Cloudo is 90% like Windows.  They seem to be big competitors.

 

I plan to try more, but if you’re like me and looking for a geek version to edit your stories from any computer then so far it looks like you’re going to be disappointed.

 

My current solution?  Box.net.  They are a provider, but they give you 1GB and you can use a REAL version of the Zoho Document Editor to edit your works.  It’s very easy to work with files and if you share a document, you can see that shared version in a great program I use called Ipaper and THAT link can be put on your website.  However, I have run into glitches.  Be careful copying and pasting from MS Word and take your time when saving your work.

 

 

 

3 comments:

icloud Beta Team said...

icloud Write opens .doc files in Office 97-2003 directly and saves it back to .doc ...

Using the file system, right click on the file and choose "Copy Internet link to Clipboard", there you have a link to share to friends! You can also using the Properties dialog create a URL to access the file with an easier file name, published under your profile, http://my.icloud.com/username/published_file, just use the Publish tab in the properties dialog.

The new version of Write launched yesterday on the June the 2nd, includes real-time spellchecking (most languages in the world) with curly lines, insertion of images directly from Flickr or Live Search and right click on any word for dictionary.

Access icloud file system directly in Windows / Mac / Linux through WebDAV, use the following application for easy installation: http://icloud.com/downloads/webdavconnector.exe

Kite said...

I will go ahead and take another look at iCloud, but it sounds like I might still fall short of my expectations. MS Word/Office isn't on every computer. The idea behind my search is to see if I can really have a desktop anywhere and everywhere, regardless of the type of computer, and have the documents linked up so someone on my website can view them in progress.

Thanks for the comment though. I'm impressed to see your team is scanning the web for reviews like mine and trying to address the issues.

Kite said...

I tried icloud again and yes you can get a link to that document as a MS Word document BUT - it is not a link directly TO that document. It's a link to DOWNLOAD that document. So my Ipaper viewer does not work. I can NOT display that written work in a pdf-like viewer for my readers.